- Isiah Maxwell 14
- Isis Love 11
- Isis Taylor 5
- Isla Biza 1
- Its Cleo VNA 2
- Ivana Sugar 1
- Ivi Rein 4
- Ivy Lebelle 3
- Ivy Lopez 1
- Ivy Rider 1
- Ivy Rose 3
- Ivy Secret 3
- Ivy Stone 1
- Ivy Winters 3
- Ivy Wolfe 1
- Izabela Pimenta 1
- Izadora Lina 1
- Izan1 1
- Izanboss 1
- Izzy Bell 2
- Izzy Lush 1
- J Mac 26
- Jack 1
- Jack Blaque 3
- Jack Cummings 1
- Jack Kallahari 8
- Jack Lawrence 2
- Jack Napier 3
- Jack Rippher 3
- Jack Vegas 5
- Jackie Hoff 2
- Jacky Joy 1
- Jacky Lawless 1
- Jaclyn Taylor 4
- Jada Doll 1
- Jada Fire 6
- Jada Stevens 22
- Jade Amor 1
- Jade Hsu 1
- Jade Jantzen 5
- Jade Kush 2
- Jade Luv 2
- Jade Maris 1
- Jade Nile 2
- Jade Presley 1
- Jai James 1
- Jaimie Vine 1
- Jakar 1
- Jake Adams 1
- Jake Mathews 1
- Jake Taylor 3
- Jake Waters 1
- James Angel 4
- James Deen 15
- James Hardon 1
- James Johnson 1
- Jamie Barry 7
- Jamie Elle 3
- Jamie Foster 2
- Jamie French 1